Robotiq case study: Never too small for cobots
Jun. 26, 2017 - Two years ago, architect Brian Vallario and finance worker Gerard Masci decided it was time to bring back something that was long gone in the American eyewear industry: the Made-in-USA label.
The two friends, without any manufacturing background, wanted to bring eyewear production back to the United States. They started their brand, Lowercase NYC, and automated their processes right from the beginning. In only five days, they’ve programmed a Universal Robot and a Robotiq’s 2-fingers gripper to operate the CNC machine by itself, allowing the three employees to focus on the countless things they have to do in this start-up business.
A five-day integration project
Before launching Lowercase, Vallario specialized in digital fabrication in an architecture firm. He didn’t know much about robots, but was aware of the benefits of automation.
“I had done a little bit of research on robots when I was in graduate school, but I never really had any working experience with them. It was a complete learning process but it went fairly smoothly. With the help of Axis New Jersey, we were put in touch with an integrator but the majority of the integration was done on our own,” he said.
Cynthia Kradjel, account manager for the New York metro area at Axis, found the perfect match for the start-up business.
“When Lowercase came to us with their design concept, our automation engineers put together a cost effective solution, yet flexible enough to be redeployed as their business grew,” she said. “We recommended Universal Robot mainly because it is collaborative, but also because it is easy for users to program it and change how they want to deploy it. As the business grows, they may want to add movements or add numbers of stops in the process that the robot does. We also chose the Robotiq Gripper as an ideal solution for this application. We felt that it will be able to accomplish the types of movements in a very repeatable and practical way. We then brought an integrator, Richlin Machinery, who was able to design a platform where the robot stands and was also able to design a solenoïd based solution so that the robot can communicate with the CNC machine and bring parts in and out as needed.”
A few months have passed and for Lowercase and Axis New Jersey, this integration, that took only a week, was a success.
“Overall, we think the solution was flexible, easy to redeploy and cost effective, compared particularly to industrial robots, which require caging, and once they’re integrated, they need to bring an integrator back to make any changes,” Kradjel said. “In the case of Lowercase, we helped train them so that they’re able to program the robot and keep it current with what they want to do on a daily basis.”
Since one of the cofounders came to the eyewear industry with a financial background, any equipment chosen to build the factory had to be worth every penny. Masci was willing to implement robotics into the production and quickly realized that the price of a robot and the price of integration were two different things.
“The cost to automate was extremely high, but we were always able to get our heads around that because of the value that the robot would add to the process. The main problem was that the integration cost of most robotic solutions was three to four times the cost of the solution itself. When we worked out a solution using the UR5 and the Robotiq gripper, the integration cost was a fraction of the actual purchase price. Then it made it tenable for a small company of two people to integrate a robot into our solution.”
Quality first: Robot-driven repeatability and consistency
The repeatability and consistency of the robot-machine combo was a huge benefit for Lowercase.
“We have 17 different styles now,” said Vallario. “We really needed something that was easy to program and that we could manipulate on the fly. If I make a change on a design, I have to be able to apply the changes quickly. And since we are competing against bigger, high-end eyewear manufacturers, we have to deliver the highest quality even if we do quite smaller productions.”
To bring its eyewear to life, Lowercase imports the material in sheets. It is cut down into small tablets and the frames are then cut in the CNC machine, which is tended by the UR5 and the Robotiq Gripper. The robot picks up the raw material, loads it into the first position, closes the door, presses the go button and then does it all over again for the second position. It then removes the finished pair of glasses and puts it in a bucket. The eyewear then goes through many steps of fine-tuning before it is ready to be shipped.
Each production batch in the CNC machine averages 500 units, with around 30 to 40 units of each style. But even with such a small volume, Vallario believes the automated process is by far the best solution.
“I only have a few manual tweaks to do on the vices every time. The rest is all automated,” he explained. “This automation is important for us. Eyewear production is a very labour-intensive process and we are such a small team that any improvement we can make on our efficiency is huge. Having a product that allows myself to sit at the computer and work on design or go work on the more labour-intensive stuff that can’t be done by machines is a big plus for us.”
The future is bright
Without seeing life through a pair of pink glasses, Vallario and Masci say they definitely see great things coming for Lowercase. Automation is an important part of many of their future projects, not only regarding the addition of new robots in the factory, but also to raise hirings, they said.
“A collaborative robot is operating our CNC machine, but we’re not hindering jobs,” said Vallario. “Automation just creates different jobs. Right now, we’re not looking for someone to operate a CNC machine, but we are looking for engineers and designers who can work with robotics to improve processes. If that helps us grow as a business, that helps creating jobs.”
And even though Lowercase’s cofounders do not think that eyewear production could be fully automated — just yet — they said they see many other opportunities to bring more robots into their team.
“As we grow, we are definitely looking for new ways to automate our processes,” continued Vallario. “A lot of time-consuming steps involved into doing a pair of glasses require delicate handwork. We’ll never be able to automate everything but there is a lot that can be done and we’re looking forward to it.”
EMC industry event: Increasing Competitiveness & CI
December 5, 2017
Additive Manufacturing Americas 2017
December 6-8, 2017
Motor & Drive Systems 2018
February 8-9, 2018
ARC Industry Forum 2018
February 12-15, 2018
Advanced Design & Manufacturing Expo 2018 Cleveland
March 7-8, 2018
Hannover Messe 2018
April 23-27, 2018