What to ask when specifying a frame grabber for machine vision applications
Jun. 8, 2017 - Over the last two decades, there has been a general trend towards the standardization of machine vision interfaces.
Not long ago, engineers were required to purchase unique and expensive cables for every camera-to-frame grabber combination, or even camera to PC interface. In some cases, different cameras from the same manufacturer required an entirely different set of cables, resulting in costly upgrades and unsatisfied customers.
Standardization has changed that, making life easier for engineers and manufacturers alike. Camera Link became a universally accepted interface in 2001 and is still going strong. CoaXPress (2011), USB3 (2013), GigE Vision (2006) and Camera Link HS (2012) are also now universally accepted interfaces for machine vision solutions. Others such as Firewire have been in the market since the 1980s but are being replaced by newer interfaces.
Nowhere has standardization been more keenly observed than in frame grabbers. Along with cameras and cables, frame grabbers are essential components in most high-end machine vision systems. Frame grabbers are essential for these high-end applications as the data rates exceed anything that can be provided by a non frame grabber solution. They are also required when complex I/O signals are introduced into the vision system. Examples of these are quarature encoders, strobes and triggers of various types.
With the introduction of high-speed communication links like Ethernet, Firewire and USB, pundits forecasted an end of the frame grabber. After all, a smart digital video camera was capable of packaging information into packets for direct feed into a PC’s communication ports, so there was no long a need for a frame grabber, right?
Not so fast. For all their hype Direct-to-PC standards are, at best, adequate for lower-end applications. Cameras are evolving at a rapid pace and now produce megapixel images at extremely fast frame and line rates, far exceeding the 120MB/s serial-interface limit. Vision engineers have found that frame grabbers offer advantages that continue to make them necessary, perhaps more now than ever before.
Specifying frame grabbers
The main component in a machine vision system that determines the frame grabber is the sensor. To find the right sensor, the customer asks themselves three questions about their machine vision solution:
• What do I need to image?
• How do I need to image it?
• When do I need to image it?
Upon deciding a choice of sensor, the customer then goes about finding which companies can offer this sensor in a package; or in other words, a camera. Next, they must determine their application’s imaging requirements to choose what performance features are needed in a frame grabber, including:
• Is there a large volume of data that needs to be acquired from the camera?
• Is there a high speed of data acquisition involved?
• What about timing?
• Are interrupts OK?
• Can the system deal with dropped or lost frames?
• Are there other components to consider such as encoders or strobes? Other I/O?
• Is it a multi-camera system?
• What is the maximum distance between the camera and the PC?
Other important questions for frame grabbers are: “How do I hook up my encoder?” or “How do I test various I/O options?” For this reason, it is important that the frame grabber have the capability of hosting a number of optional components, be it a DIN mounted I/O test fixture or a cable to get the I/O outside the PC to connect to an external I/O.
As important as these questions are, frame grabber cost can be as much of a factor as performance. For some, performance is the end-all and as such, they will specify the frame grabber that does precisely what is required no matter the price point. For others, price will dictate just how “exact” they want their system to be, or how much they can operate with certain limitations such as bandwidths and distances.
Frame grabbers are no longer exclusively used in machine vision; today, they are an essential component of dozens of industries. It is important that the frame grabber manufacturer is involved in standards committees and other groups monitoring the evolution of this fast-changing technology.
It is equally critical that the manufacturer works closely with camera manufacturers, cable companies and image processing software developers to ensure that the customer will be able to integrate its choice of components with a specific frame grabber.
Advanced Design & Manufacturing Expo 2018 Cleveland
March 7-8, 2018
North American Manufacturing Excellence Summit 2018
April 10-11, 2018
The Vision Show 2018
April 10-12, 2018
Focus On Manufacturing Security 2018
April 18, 2018
Hannover Messe 2018
April 23-27, 2018
Smart Manufacturing Experience 2018
April 30-2, 2018